Senate confirms Trump's pick for new role of fraud enforcement at Justice Department

## Summary
Law Senate confirms Trump's pick for new role of fraud enforcement at Justice Department March 24, 2026 3:06 PM ET Jaclyn Diaz Colin McDonald speaks during his Senate Judiciary Committee nomination hearing on Feb. 25, 2026 in Washington, D.C. The creation of the National Fraud Enforcement Division that McDonald will run also contributes to concerns about the independence of federal law enforcement, according to some Democratic lawmakers and former Justice Department officials. "The Justice Department has historically operated with meaningful independence from the White House in individual enforcement matters. Since Trump's return to the White House, the DOJ has investigated and in some instances prosecuted Trump's perceived political foes like New York Attorney General Letitia James and former FBI Director James Comey . (Both cases have since been dismissed.) Blanche praised McDonald as a "rockstar," while Trump in a Truth Social post announcing his nomination said he was "very smart, tough and highly respected America First federal prosecutor who has successfully delivered justice in some of the most difficult and high-stakes cases our country has ever seen." But Democratic lawmakers expressed concern about McDonald's association with the Weaponization Working Group during his nomination hearing, citing worries the prosecutor's work would be politicized. Law Trump agencies drop dozens of Biden-era cases against crypto, other companies "If the Justice Department wanted to increase fraud prosecutions, then they should be taking action to strengthen enforcement and not weakening it," Carbone, the former prosecutor, said. "The way that should be done is through the existing structure, instead of cutting resources to the fraud section." Justice Department fraud Senate confirmation Facebook Flipboard Email

## Article Content
Law
Senate confirms Trump's pick for new role of fraud enforcement at Justice Department
March 24, 2026
3:06 PM ET
Jaclyn Diaz
Colin McDonald speaks during his Senate Judiciary Committee nomination hearing on Feb. 25, 2026 in Washington, D.C.
Anna Moneymaker/Getty Images
hide caption
toggle caption
Anna Moneymaker/Getty Images
The Senate confirmed a longtime federal prosecutor to a new Justice Department role focused on prosecutions of
fraud
in government programs.
The Senate on Tuesday approved Colin McDonald's nomination 52-47 for assistant attorney general for fraud enforcement, despite concerns from Democrats about his recent work with the department and that his post could be weaponized to pursue political opponents of President Trump.
The vote comes just days after the White House
announced details about its own anti-fraud task force
that would include a representative of the Department of Justice and would also pursue fraud in government programs. Vice President JD Vance will serve as the group's chairman.
"Republicans and Democrats can and should agree: fighting fraud, particularly fraud on the American taxpayer, is important work, and that's true now more than ever," Sen. Chuck Grassley, R-Iowa, said ahead of Tuesday's vote. "What happened in Minnesota and around the country is unacceptable, and we as elected officials need to support the Justice Department in stopping this fraud."
Grassley, the chairman of the Senate Committee on the Judiciary, was referring to a long-running prosecutions of fraud in Minnesota, including in its child care programs, which was also highlighted by MAGA-aligned
social media influencers
earlier this year.
Vance announced the creation of a DOJ fraud role in January, pointing to the fraud in Minnesota, and said that position would have a direct line to the White House.
"This is the person that is going to make sure we stop defrauding the American people," Vance said at the time.
Trump in his State of the Union speech later announced a "
war on fraud
" to root out corruption in places like Minnesota, and put Vance in charge of it.
Politics
Influencer, White House welfare fraud claims are distorted, but the system has risks
McDonald, like other agency representatives, will presumably be a part of this "government-wide" effort,"
as the White House has described
this Vance-led task force. The White House and the Department of Justice didn't respond to detailed questions about how the two efforts would work together.
The creation of the National Fraud Enforcement Division that McDonald will run also contributes to concerns about the independence of federal law enforcement, according to some Democratic lawmakers and former Justice Department officials.
"The Justice Department has historically operated with meaningful independence from the White House in individual enforcement matters. When you have statements like we have here suggesting that any new fraud enforcement office would be answerable to the White House, that raises legitimate concerns," said Perry Carbone, a former federal prosecutor. He was pointing to Vance's comments about McDonald having a direct line to the White House.
Carbone, now an adjunct professor at Pace University, spent 30 years with the DOJ focusing on white collar, public corruption and tax cases. He said the DOJ already has longstanding, and fruitful, units that investigate fraud across a range of areas and coordinate nationwide cases, making this new creation redundant.
Health
The threats to Minnesota's Medicaid funds are unprecedented. Other states could be next
"Fraud enforcement requires credibility that decisions are based on evidence and law, and not political considerations," he said.
Minnesota Democratic Sen. Amy Klobuchar asked McDonald about such concerns
during his Senate confirmation hearing
last month.
McDonald — who prior to confirmation served as an associate deputy attorney general in the office of Deputy Attorney General Todd Blanche — said his goal as a career federal prosecutor is to uncover and follow the facts and apply them to the law.
He said he wants "to make sure every case I bring is fair and is just."
When asked who he would report to, he simply said he would report to Blanche; he confirmed that in
subsequent written responses
to the committee.
Politics
New attorney general moves to align Justice Department with Trump's priorities
Background as a federal prosecutor
McDonald's most recent work at the DOJ also prompted some questions from lawmakers.
McDonald worked as a federal prosecutor for about a decade in the Southern District of California in San Diego, his hometown.
He moved to Washington, D.C. with his wife and five children to work with Blanche.
That included supervising the DOJ's Weaponization Working Group, which Attorney General Bondi established "to restore integrity and credibility with the public" of the DOJ's work.
Law
Justice Department says it will defend Trump's order targeting 4 law firms
The working grou

---

## Expert Analysis

### Merits
- Vice President JD Vance will serve as the group's chairman. "Republicans and Democrats can and should agree: fighting fraud, particularly fraud on the American taxpayer, is important work, and that's true now more than ever," Sen.
- During the hearing, he dodged specifics on his work with the group, and said it was important to understand "what happened" during the Biden administration.
- The GAO said the USDA's Food and Nutrition Service, the federal agency responsible for these benefits, "has not comprehensively assessed what benefit theft prevention measures state SNAP agencies are implementing, including those it recommended in October 2022." Vance said the focus won't just be on Minnesota. "We also want to expand this.
- One man explains why he breaks a rule "As significant and problematic as health care fraud is, for many years, the Justice Department has had very effective means of coordinating in long-standing ways with the FBI, HHS and other agencies to pursue all kinds of health care fraud," he said.

### Areas for Consideration
- Since Trump's return to the White House, the DOJ has investigated and in some instances prosecuted Trump's perceived political foes like New York Attorney General Letitia James and former FBI Director James Comey . (Both cases have since been dismissed.) Blanche praised McDonald as a "rockstar," while Trump in a Truth Social post announcing his nomination said he was "very smart, tough and highly respected America First federal prosecutor who has successfully delivered justice in some of the most difficult and high-stakes cases our country has ever seen." But Democratic lawmakers expressed concern about McDonald's association with the Weaponization Working Group during his nomination hearing, citing worries the prosecutor's work would be politicized.
- The Government Accountability Office published a report last September that said recipients of SNAP benefits have reported more than $320 million in stolen benefits, though that was due in part to SNAP cards lacking meaningful theft-prevention features like microchips.
- McDonald responded directly to speculation that this fraud division would be redundant during his testimony to the Senate Judiciary Committee . "The issue of fraud, waste and abuse in the country is so vast.

### Implications
- The Senate on Tuesday approved Colin McDonald's nomination 52-47 for assistant attorney general for fraud enforcement, despite concerns from Democrats about his recent work with the department and that his post could be weaponized to pursue political opponents of President Trump.
- Vice President JD Vance will serve as the group's chairman. "Republicans and Democrats can and should agree: fighting fraud, particularly fraud on the American taxpayer, is important work, and that's true now more than ever," Sen.
- Politics Influencer, White House welfare fraud claims are distorted, but the system has risks McDonald, like other agency representatives, will presumably be a part of this "government-wide" effort," as the White House has described this Vance-led task force.
- The creation of the National Fraud Enforcement Division that McDonald will run also contributes to concerns about the independence of federal law enforcement, according to some Democratic lawmakers and former Justice Department officials. "The Justice Department has historically operated with meaningful independence from the White House in individual enforcement matters.

### Expert Commentary
This article covers fraud, department, federal topics. Notable strengths include discussion of fraud. Areas of concern are also raised. Readability: Flesch-Kincaid grade 0.0. Word count: 1761.