How Canada's largest gun control effort in decades is missing the mark

## Summary
How Canada's largest gun control effort in decades is missing the mark 40 minutes ago Share Save Add as preferred on Google Nadine Yousif Senior Canada reporter, Montreal, Quebec BBC Gun shop owner Frank Nardi says many clients are confused by the gun-buy back programme and which firearms fall under the ban Heidi Rathjen has been calling for a ban on assault-style rifles since 1989, when a gunman opened fire on her classmates at Montreal's École Polytechnique. Many legal gun owners are distrustful of the process, two provinces have refused to take part, and even gun control activists like Rathjen say the federal efforts, though a win for public safety, are flawed because the ban does not apply widely enough. "Without a comprehensive ban on assault weapons, there is no ban… and the money will be wasted," said Rathjen, a spokesperson for gun control advocacy group PolySeSouvient. Even Canada's own minister of public safety, Gary Anandasangaree, was caught criticising his government's plan in an audio clip leaked to the Toronto Star. "Don't ask me to explain the logic to you on this," he told a Toronto man in a secretly recorded conversation late last year, when pressed on programme's value when most gun crimes in Canada are committed with illegal weapons. Supplied by PolySeSouvient Gun control activist Heidi Rathjen says the gun ban excludes model like the SKS, a semi-automatic firearm Canada's plan is for gun owners is to be reimbursed by the government when they turn in their weapons, similar to measures in Australia and New Zealand.

## Article Content
How Canada's largest gun control effort in decades is missing the mark
40 minutes ago
Share
Save
Add as preferred on Google
Nadine Yousif
Senior Canada reporter, Montreal, Quebec
BBC
Gun shop owner Frank Nardi says many clients are confused by the gun-buy back programme and which firearms fall under the ban
Heidi Rathjen has been calling for a ban on assault-style rifles since 1989, when a gunman opened fire on her classmates at Montreal's École Polytechnique.
The shooting, in which 14 women were killed and more than a dozen injured, was a turning point for Canada, changing how the country viewed gun violence.
More than two decades later, after another deadly mass shooting in 2020, Ottawa did roll out a ban on some 2,500 models of such "assault-style" weapons.
But a scheme designed to buy back these now-prohibited guns from their owners has had a bumpy roll out, and the programme looks likely to miss the mark.
Many legal gun owners are distrustful of the process, two provinces have refused to take part, and even gun control activists like Rathjen say the federal efforts, though a win for public safety, are flawed because the ban does not apply widely enough.
"Without a comprehensive ban on assault weapons, there is no ban… and the money will be wasted," said Rathjen, a spokesperson for gun control advocacy group PolySeSouvient.
Even Canada's own minister of public safety,
Gary Anandasangaree, was caught criticising his government's plan in an audio clip leaked to the Toronto Star.
"Don't ask me to explain the logic to you on this," he told a Toronto man in a secretly recorded conversation late last year, when pressed on programme's value when most gun crimes in Canada are committed with illegal weapons.
Anandasangaree later said his comments were "misguided", and that he believes in the programme's importance.
So why is Canada struggling with a measure that saw success in places like Australia - where 650,000 firearms were bought back and destroyed after the Port Arthur massacre in 1996, according to figures by the Australian government - and New Zealand, which collected around 56,000 firearms after the Christchurch mosque shooting in 2019?
Australia was seen as a world leader in gun control - Bondi has exposed a more complicated reality
What are Canada's gun ownership laws?
Joel Negin, a professor of public health at the University of Sydney, said Australia's measures in 1996 largely worked because they were part of a broad suite of measures implemented "very quickly" after the massacre.
Australia's programme was also well-funded thanks to a short-term levy that was placed on taxpayers, he noted.
"The situation in Canada is that the gun buy-back has been proposed, but it's not necessarily linked closely to other interventions," Negin said, adding its roll out, along with other gun-related laws after the 2020 Nova Scotia mass shooting, has been fragmented.
Supplied by PolySeSouvient
Gun control activist Heidi Rathjen says the gun ban excludes model like the SKS, a semi-automatic firearm
Canada's plan is for gun owners is to be reimbursed by the government when they turn in their weapons, similar to measures in Australia and New Zealand. More than C$215m ($155m; £117m) has been set aside for the effort.
Canada marks 30 years since Montreal Massacre
Frank Nardi, a Montreal-based gun shop owner, said he believes the law unfairly targets lawful hunters and sport shooters. He argues that mass shootings in Canada are more likely linked to things like failures in the mental health system.
"Let's concentrate on that before slapping all these regulations and confiscations on all these legal firearm owners, who have always supported safety and followed the protocols," he said.
Speaking at his shop, Nardi told the BBC he's heard from many gun owners who are confused about the programme and unsure of which guns are affected, which he blamed on poor communication from the federal government.
He argues that the firearms that fall under the ban - or don't - don't always make sense. He holds up two that appear nearly identical.
"Same caliber, all the same type of cartridges," he explained, but one is banned while the other is not.
Meanwhile, Alberta and Saskatchewan, two conservative provinces in western Canada, have refused to participate in the programme.
In Alberta it won't be enforced and in Saskatchewan, owners will be shielded from criminal liability until they receive what the province says is a guarantee of fair compensation for their guns.
Blaine Beaven, Saskatchewan's newly appointed firearms commissioner, told the BBC his province's law is designed to protect gun owners. But he and other Saskatchewan officials have had strong words for the firearm ban itself.
"At its core, it's an ideological mandate that's being put out there that has limited to no discernible benefit to public safety," Beaven said.
Watch: Breaking down Canada’s gun buyback scheme
A number of police forces in Canada have said they will not as

---

## Expert Analysis

### Merits
- Many legal gun owners are distrustful of the process, two provinces have refused to take part, and even gun control activists like Rathjen say the federal efforts, though a win for public safety, are flawed because the ban does not apply widely enough. "Without a comprehensive ban on assault weapons, there is no ban… and the money will be wasted," said Rathjen, a spokesperson for gun control advocacy group PolySeSouvient.
- So why is Canada struggling with a measure that saw success in places like Australia - where 650,000 firearms were bought back and destroyed after the Port Arthur massacre in 1996, according to figures by the Australian government - and New Zealand, which collected around 56,000 firearms after the Christchurch mosque shooting in 2019?
- But he and other Saskatchewan officials have had strong words for the firearm ban itself. "At its core, it's an ideological mandate that's being put out there that has limited to no discernible benefit to public safety," Beaven said.
- Watch: Breaking down Canada’s gun buyback scheme A number of police forces in Canada have said they will not assist the government in the programme, calling it a "significant operational burden" and saying it may not align with their priority of focusing on illegal gun smuggling instead.

### Areas for Consideration
- Many legal gun owners are distrustful of the process, two provinces have refused to take part, and even gun control activists like Rathjen say the federal efforts, though a win for public safety, are flawed because the ban does not apply widely enough. "Without a comprehensive ban on assault weapons, there is no ban… and the money will be wasted," said Rathjen, a spokesperson for gun control advocacy group PolySeSouvient.
- Getty Images Public Safety Minister Gary Anandasangaree has said "assault-style" weapons don't belong in Canadian communities The Canadian government has said it intends to go ahead fully with the buy-back scheme despite criticism around their policy.
- The Supreme Court of Canada recently agreed to hear a challenge to the gun ban by the Canadian Coalition of Firearm Rights, after two lower courts upheld it.

### Implications
- Many legal gun owners are distrustful of the process, two provinces have refused to take part, and even gun control activists like Rathjen say the federal efforts, though a win for public safety, are flawed because the ban does not apply widely enough. "Without a comprehensive ban on assault weapons, there is no ban… and the money will be wasted," said Rathjen, a spokesperson for gun control advocacy group PolySeSouvient.
- In Alberta it won't be enforced and in Saskatchewan, owners will be shielded from criminal liability until they receive what the province says is a guarantee of fair compensation for their guns.
- Watch: Breaking down Canada’s gun buyback scheme A number of police forces in Canada have said they will not assist the government in the programme, calling it a "significant operational burden" and saying it may not align with their priority of focusing on illegal gun smuggling instead.
- Getty Images Public Safety Minister Gary Anandasangaree has said "assault-style" weapons don't belong in Canadian communities The Canadian government has said it intends to go ahead fully with the buy-back scheme despite criticism around their policy.

### Expert Commentary
This article covers gun, canada, ban topics. Notable strengths include discussion of gun. Areas of concern are also raised. Readability: Flesch-Kincaid grade 0.0. Word count: 1367.