Minimum-Action Learning: Energy-Constrained Symbolic Model Selection for Physical Law Identification from Noisy Data
arXiv:2603.16951v1 Announce Type: new Abstract: Identifying physical laws from noisy observational data is a central challenge in scientific machine learning. We present Minimum-Action Learning (MAL), a framework that selects symbolic force laws from a pre-specified basis library by minimizing a Triple-Action functional combining trajectory reconstruction, architectural sparsity, and energy-conservation enforcement. A wide-stencil acceleration-matching technique reduces noise variance by 10,000x, transforming an intractable problem (SNR ~0.02) into a learnable one (SNR ~1.6); this preprocessing is the critical enabler shared by all methods tested, including SINDy variants. On two benchmarks -- Kepler gravity and Hooke's law -- MAL recovers the correct force law with Kepler exponent p = 3.01 +/- 0.01 at ~0.07 kWh (40% reduction vs. prediction-error-only baselines). The raw correct-basis rate is 40% for Kepler and 90% for Hooke; an energy-conservation-based criterion discriminates the t
arXiv:2603.16951v1 Announce Type: new Abstract: Identifying physical laws from noisy observational data is a central challenge in scientific machine learning. We present Minimum-Action Learning (MAL), a framework that selects symbolic force laws from a pre-specified basis library by minimizing a Triple-Action functional combining trajectory reconstruction, architectural sparsity, and energy-conservation enforcement. A wide-stencil acceleration-matching technique reduces noise variance by 10,000x, transforming an intractable problem (SNR ~0.02) into a learnable one (SNR ~1.6); this preprocessing is the critical enabler shared by all methods tested, including SINDy variants. On two benchmarks -- Kepler gravity and Hooke's law -- MAL recovers the correct force law with Kepler exponent p = 3.01 +/- 0.01 at ~0.07 kWh (40% reduction vs. prediction-error-only baselines). The raw correct-basis rate is 40% for Kepler and 90% for Hooke; an energy-conservation-based criterion discriminates the true force law in all cases, yielding 100% pipeline-level identification. Basis library sensitivity experiments show that near-confounders degrade selection (20% with added r^{-2.5} and r^{-1.5}), while distant additions are harmless, and the conservation diagnostic remains informative even when the correct basis is absent. Direct comparison with noise-robust SINDy variants, Hamiltonian Neural Networks, and Lagrangian Neural Networks confirms MAL's distinct niche: interpretable, energy-constrained model selection that combines symbolic basis identification with dynamical rollout validation.
Executive Summary
This article introduces Minimum-Action Learning (MAL), a novel framework for identifying physical laws from noisy observational data. MAL combines trajectory reconstruction, architectural sparsity, and energy-conservation enforcement to select symbolic force laws from a pre-specified basis library. The framework demonstrates a 40% reduction in energy consumption compared to prediction-error-only baselines and achieves 100% pipeline-level identification on two benchmarks. The authors' wide-stencil acceleration-matching technique reduces noise variance by 10,000x, transforming an intractable problem into a learnable one. MAL's distinct niche is its interpretable, energy-constrained model selection that combines symbolic basis identification with dynamical rollout validation.
Key Points
- ▸ MAL combines trajectory reconstruction, architectural sparsity, and energy-conservation enforcement to select symbolic force laws.
- ▸ The framework achieves 100% pipeline-level identification on two benchmarks.
- ▸ MAL's distinct niche is its interpretable, energy-constrained model selection.
Merits
Strength in Noise Reduction
MAL's wide-stencil acceleration-matching technique reduces noise variance by 10,000x, enabling the identification of physical laws from noisy data.
Interpretability
MAL provides interpretable results by selecting symbolic force laws from a pre-specified basis library.
Energy Efficiency
MAL demonstrates a 40% reduction in energy consumption compared to prediction-error-only baselines.
Demerits
Limited Generalizability
The framework's performance may be limited to specific physical systems and noise characteristics.
Sensitivity to Basis Library
MAL's performance is sensitive to the choice of basis library, which may require careful selection or adaptation.
Expert Commentary
This article presents a significant advancement in scientific machine learning, addressing the critical challenge of identifying physical laws from noisy data. MAL's unique combination of trajectory reconstruction, architectural sparsity, and energy-conservation enforcement enables the selection of symbolic force laws from a pre-specified basis library. The framework's performance is impressive, achieving 100% pipeline-level identification on two benchmarks. However, further research is needed to explore MAL's generalizability to various physical systems and noise characteristics. Additionally, the sensitivity of MAL to the choice of basis library requires careful consideration. Overall, MAL has the potential to revolutionize our understanding of physical laws and their applications in various fields.
Recommendations
- ✓ Future research should focus on exploring MAL's generalizability to various physical systems and noise characteristics.
- ✓ Careful selection or adaptation of the basis library is essential to ensure MAL's optimal performance.