Academic

CodeScout: Contextual Problem Statement Enhancement for Software Agents

arXiv:2603.05744v1 Announce Type: new Abstract: Current AI-powered code assistance tools often struggle with poorly-defined problem statements that lack sufficient task context and requirements specification. Recent analysis of software engineering agents reveals that failures on such underspecified requests are highly correlated with longer trajectories involving either over-exploration or repeated attempts at applying the same fix without proper evolution or testing, leading to suboptimal outcomes across software development tasks. We introduce CodeScout, a contextual query refinement approach that systematically converts underspecified user requests into comprehensive, actionable problem statements through lightweight pre-exploration of the target codebase. Our key innovation is demonstrating that structured analysis before task execution can supplement existing agentic capabilities without requiring any modifications to their underlying scaffolds. CodeScout performs targeted conte

arXiv:2603.05744v1 Announce Type: new Abstract: Current AI-powered code assistance tools often struggle with poorly-defined problem statements that lack sufficient task context and requirements specification. Recent analysis of software engineering agents reveals that failures on such underspecified requests are highly correlated with longer trajectories involving either over-exploration or repeated attempts at applying the same fix without proper evolution or testing, leading to suboptimal outcomes across software development tasks. We introduce CodeScout, a contextual query refinement approach that systematically converts underspecified user requests into comprehensive, actionable problem statements through lightweight pre-exploration of the target codebase. Our key innovation is demonstrating that structured analysis before task execution can supplement existing agentic capabilities without requiring any modifications to their underlying scaffolds. CodeScout performs targeted context scoping, conducts multi-perspective analysis examining potential fixes and exploration opportunities, then synthesizes these insights into enhanced problem statements with reproduction steps, expected behaviors, and targeted exploration hints. This pre-exploration directly addresses the identified failure patterns by reducing non-converging agent trajectories while clarifying user intent in natural language space. We evaluate CodeScout using state-of-the-art agentic scaffolds and language models on SWEBench-Verified, demonstrating a 20\% improvement in resolution rates with up to 27 additional issues resolved compared to the default baseline method. Our results suggest that systematic query refinement through contextual analysis represents a promising direction for enhancing AI code assistance capabilities.

Executive Summary

This article introduces CodeScout, a contextual query refinement approach designed to enhance AI-powered code assistance tools. CodeScout addresses the issue of poorly-defined problem statements by systematically converting user requests into comprehensive, actionable problem statements. The approach involves pre-exploration of the target codebase, multi-perspective analysis, and synthesis of insights into enhanced problem statements. Evaluation using state-of-the-art agentic scaffolds and language models on SWEBench-Verified demonstrates a 20% improvement in resolution rates and up to 27 additional issues resolved. The results suggest that systematic query refinement through contextual analysis represents a promising direction for enhancing AI code assistance capabilities.

Key Points

  • CodeScout is a contextual query refinement approach designed to enhance AI-powered code assistance tools.
  • CodeScout addresses the issue of poorly-defined problem statements through systematic conversion into comprehensive, actionable problem statements.
  • Evaluation using state-of-the-art agentic scaffolds and language models on SWEBench-Verified demonstrates improved resolution rates and additional issue resolution.

Merits

Strength in Addressing Underspecified Requests

CodeScout directly addresses the issue of poorly-defined problem statements, a common failure point in AI-powered code assistance tools.

Improved Resolution Rates

Evaluation results demonstrate a 20% improvement in resolution rates and up to 27 additional issues resolved, indicating the effectiveness of the approach.

Promising Direction for Enhancing AI Code Assistance

The results suggest that systematic query refinement through contextual analysis represents a promising direction for enhancing AI code assistance capabilities.

Demerits

Potential Overhead in Pre-Exploration

The pre-exploration component of CodeScout may introduce additional overhead, potentially impacting the overall efficiency of the approach.

Dependence on State-of-the-Art Agentic Scaffolds and Language Models

The evaluation of CodeScout relies on state-of-the-art agentic scaffolds and language models, which may limit the generalizability of the results.

Expert Commentary

CodeScout represents a significant advancement in the field of AI-powered code assistance, addressing a common failure point in these tools. The evaluation results are compelling, and the approach has the potential to improve resolution rates and issue resolution. However, the potential overhead of pre-exploration and dependence on state-of-the-art agentic scaffolds and language models are limitations that should be addressed. The implications of CodeScout are far-reaching, with potential applications in software development and the development of more effective AI-powered code assistance tools.

Recommendations

  • Further research is needed to investigate the scalability and generalizability of CodeScout in different software development contexts.
  • The development of more efficient pre-exploration techniques and the integration of CodeScout with other AI-powered code assistance tools are recommended.

Sources